tracking image
Illinois Land Broker

Toby Stay

  • Cell: 217-257-6096
  • Office: 217-899-1240
  • Fax: 309-213-1642
Call Toby Text Toby

About Toby

Toby Stay has been a full-time Land Broker with LandGuys for 14 years. Prior to becoming a broker, he was a professional hunting guide for over 20 years. During this time, he has used his passion for the outdoors and knowledge of the whitetail deer to guide hunters to their trophy of a lifetime. Toby himself is also an accomplished bow hunter and has harvested many trophy animals. As a part of LandGuys, Toby puts his experience and knowledge of assessing and creating productive trophy properties to work for you. Whether you are listing a property or in the market to buy, Toby believes in an honest up front approach to ensure satisfaction with your decision to list or invest in Illinois hunting land.

-Member of the National Association of REALTORS®

Licensed in Illinois (475.136304): LandGuys, LLC of Illinois | Springfield, IL

 

Testimonials

“We were very satisfied with Toby’s work on our behalf.  With all his local knowledge of land and people in Brown County, he was able to provide us with a farm that fit everything on our wish list.  I’d highly recommend him.“

Michael Buckley

October 2024

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“Very happy with everything. Very professional and it was an absolute pleasure working with everyone   On a one to ten scale. Ten for sure. Thank you very much for making this as easy as possible.“

Ron and Collin Goode

June 2024

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“I worked with Toby Stay at Land Guys Realty to buy a property in Illinois. It was a pleasure to work with Toby. He was extremely professional throughout the process and he knew what I was looking for in a farm. Toby came through for me and did a great job in making the process as easiest as possible. I’d highly recommend Toby to anyone looking to buy/sell land in Illinois.“

The Valdes Family

June 2024

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“If you’re looking for a farm Toby Stay is your guy. Very knowledgeable and easy to work with. And if whitetail hunting is your desire you hit the jackpot. Toby’s knowledge of whitetail habitat and hunting tactics is an added bonus.“

Bill Walden

April 2024

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“Good service and responsive to all questions.Transactions went smoothly and super easy. I would definitely do business with Toby and LandGuys again.“

John Astrowski

February 2024

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“Toby did a great job. We had been looking for our first farm for several months. Toby shared one with us that wasn’t yet listed and was able to help facilitate a deal with the seller. I travel a lot for work so the flexibility Toby offered along with remote closing etc helped make it a very smooth process. He also got some info for us like buck history, tree plantings, past food plots, shed hunting, general deer movement etc to help us get a jump start learning the property.“

Jason McManus

February 2024

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“If you are in the market for high quality hunting ground in IL, IA, or MO, I strongly recommend you call Toby Stay. He has a gift for finding incredible farms. My experience working with Toby was professional, seamless, and enjoyable.“

Zachary Womble

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“So many people call themselves land specialist, only for you later realize they are not. Toby Stay is actually the best Land Specialist/Realtor I have ever met. In fact I trusted him enough that when he called me and said I have found exactly what you were looking for I bought the farm sight unseen! I was floored when I finally walked the property after closing and I couldn’t be happier!!! If you are looking for real estate in Illinois or Iowa I would only call Toby. I have been in and around the real estate industry via banking and insurance for the last 27 years an I assure you he won’t let you down!!!.“

Timothy Radcliff

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“Toby sold me the farm and sold the farm for me. He has always been very professional and I consider him a good friend. Thank you.“

Jay West

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“Toby Stay was extremely helpful and quickly responded to any / all questions.“

Mike Bombardiere

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“Used Toby and land guys on two property purchases and sales was amazing. Great to work with“

Jamy Flory

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“Excellent communication throughout the entire process. Toby and team are wonderful people and I highly recommend them for your real estate needs.“

Tjse C

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“Toby Stay with Landguys has made my experience with buying and selling Illinois hunting property stress free. I look forward to Toby helping me with my next buying/selling investment.“

PJ

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“Toby is great to deal with! Super professional, works in a timely manner and truly knows his stuff! Whether it comes to Hunting Properties, or Homes I’ll always call Toby first!“

Dylan Thomsen

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“Toby is a notch above the rest! His knowledge of land/hunting is one of a kind. It’s not too often you can find a realtor that is so well rounded! He has a great understanding of land, values, the present market, and last but not least….. A WHITETAIL MASTERMIND!“

Alex Carr

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“Toby Stay Is top notch and his accomplishments as a hunter allow him to understand the type of ground he is selling and provide a tremendous amount of value in helping with ideas on how to setup your dream hunting farm!“

Bobby Kendall

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“TI’ve had the pleasure of working with Toby Stay, and LandGuys, during five purchase/sale transactions, and all have gone incredibly smoothly. Toby knows the market well, knows property well, and has an abundance of hunting knowledge. He’s a true professional, and I couldn’t be happier with the service provided, and highly recommend Toby, and LandGuys both.“

Chris Sonetz

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

Toby is phenomenal. Very professional a pleasure to work with. I look forward to my purchase.

“Toby is phenomenal. Very professional a pleasure to work with. I look forward to my purchase.“

Brenda Bloom

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“Toby Stay is extremely motivated and knowledgeable in all aspects of land“

Ben Rising

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“I’ve purchased three properties with Toby, and his knowledge, not only of the market, but of hunting and land management, are exceptional.  He’s also very humble, and works hard, which, overall, makes for a great combination in assisting one’s search for hunting properties.  If the opportunity presents itself to utilize Toby’s expertise, I’d highly recommend doing so“

Chris Sonetz

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“Thank you for all you did for us! Toby went above and beyond what any real estate agent has ever done for us before, between looking for a new house and land to the negotiations process to the fine details of closing. I would use Toby again for sure.“

Scott Tozier
Brown County, IL

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“Toby and Don did a wonderful job of selling both parcels I had for sale one, in Fulton County, one in Putnam County. They were only on the market for a few days – great job guys. Thank you. Look forward to doing business in the future.“

LeRoy Poignant
Fulton County, IL

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“Toby was so good that there was never a question that went unanswered.  It didn’t matter what time of day or night he was there for any concerns I had.  He does an outstanding job.“

Penny Drake
Adams County, IL

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

“We were very happy with the service we received from the Landguys. We would recommend others to use their services. Thanks“

David Ley
Adams County, IL

Listings

Sort:

⟶ A-Z

⟶ Acres

⟶ State

⟶ County

⟶ Price
Pending
IllinoisBrown County
2.5 Acres $325,000
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1800 Sqft

1800 sqft home sits on 2.5 acres overlooking a beautiful pond.

New
IllinoisBrown County
21 Acres $187,950

21 Acres in Brown County, IL.

New
IllinoisBrown County
22 Acres $196,900

22 acres in Brown co IL.

Active
IllinoisBrown County
73 Acres $478,150

High quality hunting tract conveniently located near Mt Sterling, IL.

Pending
IllinoisBrown County
95 Acres $0

SALE PENDING

Pending
IllinoisFulton County
29 Acres $199,609

Great small acreage, 29 acres, hunting tract in Fulton Co. IL.

Pending
IllinoisJersey County
160 Acres $0

SALE PENDING

TurnKey Pending
IllinoisPike County
1320 Acres $14,950,000
  • 4 Beds
  • 3.5 Baths
  • 6000 Sqft

This is hands down one of the best trophy deer hunting properties on the planet!

Sold
IllinoisAdams County
16 Acres $365,000
  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1800 Sqft

Rare opportunity to own beautiful lodge with 16 recreational acres.

Sold
IllinoisAdams County
40 Acres $241,151

High quality, small acreage, hunting tract, close to Quincy, IL.

Sold
IllinoisAdams County
85 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisAdams County
135 Acres $0

SOLD

TurnKey Sold
IllinoisBrown County
12 Acres $275,000
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1369 Sqft

This is a very rare opportunity to own one of the most requested properties there is.

Sold
IllinoisBrown County
40 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisBrown County
40 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisBrown County
40 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisBrown County
45 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisBrown County
66 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisBrown County
68 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisBrown County
80 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisBrown County
114 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisBrown County
156 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisBrown County
160 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisBrown County
203 Acres $1,360,000
  • 2 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • Sqft

203 acres with cabin and machine shed in Brown Co IL

Sold
IllinoisBrown County
321 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisCalhoun County
161 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisFulton County
19 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisFulton County
40 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisFulton County
40 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisFulton County
58 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisHancock County
40 Acres $254,000

This property is a must see if you are looking for a high caliber hunting tract.

Sold
IllinoisHancock County
40 Acres $250,000

Extremely impressive 40 acre tract in Hancock County with potential homesite and utilities present.

Sold
IllinoisHancock County
42 Acres $266,700

This is one of the more impressive small acreage tracts on the market.

Sold
IllinoisHancock County
56 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisHancock County
68 Acres $268,600

Big Buck Travel Corridor.

Sold
IllinoisHancock County
80 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisJersey County
160 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisMcDonough County
30.5 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisMcDonough County
31 Acres $151,222

Top notch hunting farm at an affordable price!

Sold
IllinoisMcDonough County
49 Acres $262,150

Very diverse, high quality, hunting tract with multiple food plot locations with a creek and a pond.

Sold
IllinoisMcDonough County
54 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisMcDonough County
60 Acres $337,425

60 secluded hunting and fishing acres, with good income, and great recreational opportunities.

Sold
IllinoisMcDonough County
83 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisPike County
1 Acres $195,000
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1700 Sqft

1 acre with home and machine shed in Pike co IL.

Tillable Sold
IllinoisPike County
12 Acres $99,500

Small acreage with huge potential, Pike Co, IL, 12 Acres.

Sold
IllinoisPike County
38 Acres $249,000

38 acres in prime hunting county, with great access, creeks, and borders a large block of timber.

Sold
IllinoisPike County
43 Acres $322,285

Great hunting with impressive ROI on 43 acres in Pike Co.

Tillable Sold
IllinoisPike County
47 Acres $352,265

Quality hunting in Pike Co. with strong annual income.

Sold
IllinoisPike County
80 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisPike County
120 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisPike County
287 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisSchuyler County
25 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisSchuyler County
40 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisSchuyler County
48 Acres $0

(SOLD)

Sold
IllinoisSchuyler County
58 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisSchuyler County
58 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisSchuyler County
243 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisSchuyler County
245 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisShelby County
40 Acres $0

SOLD

Sold
IllinoisShelby County
46 Acres $228,500

The thickest cover in the area with a major waterway flowing the length of property.

Sold
IllinoisShelby County
93 Acres $0

SOLD

Mini Cart 0

Your cart is empty.